• LAURA ADNEY
    • ABOUT
    • services
    • FAQ
    • PRESS
    • Disclosures
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Tools
  • outfits
  • MOTHERHOOD
  • TRAVEL
  • + more
    • AT HOME
    • BEAUTY + HAIR
    • DIY
    • EVENTS
    • GIFT GUIDES
    • HEALTH + FITNESS
    • LABEL FOR LESS
  • SHOP LUXURY RESALE
  • CONTACT

Have Need Want

fashion & lifestyle blog

Madewell Colorblock Cardigan + Amazon Fashion Dupe Comparison

October 28, 2019

FacebookTwitterPinterestMixEmail

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

I absolutely love my Madewell colorblock cardigan that I scored during the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale. It sold out super quick and while I was crossing my fingers for a restock it didn’t come till after the sale was over. I found a dupe on Amazon that I wanted to compare it to, since the images on Amazon were that of another blogger wearing the Madewell cardigan. I absolutely HATE when Amazon fashion brands steal images to use to promote their similar product. We all know that they’re dupes and definitely not going to be the same quality.

But, I was so curious to see how similar they were going to be. So I decided to order one in the same color combo to do a side by side comparison for you. Since I know that many of you love the price point you can get on Amazon, and lot’s of you really wanted that cardigan, I felt the need to share.

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

First thing to note, is that the fabric is not at all the same. The Madewell color block cardigan has mohair in it, which is what gives it that soft and cozy feel. The Amazon cardigan is a lightweight material and it not cozy in the slightest. This cardigan would be great for Fall transition when it’s not quite cold enough yet for a thicker cardigan.

Second thing to note, is the fit. I ordered a size small in both the Madewell cardigan and the Amazon cardigan. In Madewell I would normally order an XS but it sold out before I could get my hands on it. The fit is very oversized, which I love. It’s like being wrapped up in a soft blanket that you can go out in public in. The Amazon cardigan is not oversized. It has a higher fit around the arms. And again, being a thinner material the fit is just way different. The length is spot on though. They both hit me right at the same spot on my thigh.

Third thing to note, is the colors. While the Amazon cardigan does a good job of matching the colors of the Madewell cardigan, due to the material the colors read a lot more bold in the Amazon cardigan. The yarn of the Madewell cardigan gives a softer tone. The pink is more muted and so is the chestnut brown. The yarn is also not totally solid (hope that makes sense) and so there is more depth to the color.

xSide by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

So those are the major differences. Now onto my thoughts on the Amazon cardigan. I have to say that for the price it’s really nice. I like that it’s lightweight and a great layering piece to make your outfits feel like fall even if its still hot outside. We’ve been experiencing high 80s to low 90s temps yet again and so while I’ve wanted to wear my Madewell colorblock cardigan, it literally makes no sense.

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

Shop the look:



As always, thank you so much for stopping by the blog today!

Pin this for later and please share with your friends!

Side by side comparison of this fall color block cardigan on Have Need Want! I found a dupe for the Madewell cardigan I love and so I had to compare. Click on over to the post to read the key differences. #madewellcardigan #fallstyle #falloutfit #amazonfashion

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Related

FacebookTwitterPinterestMixEmail

Related posts:

  1. Under $35 Fall Amazon Haul
  2. Colorblock Sweater
  3. Amazing Amazon Fashion Finds All Under $30!
  4. Orange Colorblock Sweater

Leave a Comment
Filed Under: Fashion & Style

« Orange Colorblock Sweater
Three Ways to Wear: Western Inspired Suede Booties »
Welcome to the blog! My name is Laura Adney and I am a stay at home mom to my sons Mason James and Cooper Ford. Fashion has always been a passion of mine and I love to share my personal style, lifestyle, motherhood, travel adventures, and more! Visit my about page to learn more and thank you so much for stopping by!

Subscribe to

SHOP MY CURATED LUXURY RESALE SHOP!

Privacy

By using this website, and entering your email and name to comment or subscribe, you agree to our privacy policy. You can read our privacy policy here.

Instagram

SHOP THE FEED

Top Posts

Safari Themed Nursery

Beautiful outdoor spaces to help inspire you to elevate your outdoor living. #outdoorspaces #outdooroasis #outdoorliving

Beautiful Outdoor Living Spaces

Fall decor and home inspiration on Have Need Want! Rounding up my current Fall home inspiration to help you get into the season! #fallhomedecor #fall #homeinspiration #homedecor

Favorite Fall Decor and Interior Inspiration

Amazing Amazon Fashion Finds All Under $30! Head over to the blog to check out all my finds!! #amazonfashion #tryonhaul #tryonsession #amazontryonhaul #amazonfinds #fashionunder30 #affordablefashion #affordablespringfashion

Amazing Amazon Fashion Finds All Under $30!

LaseMD Laser Facial Treatment, Laser Skincare Treatment, Refined Dermatology, Bay Area Skincare, Have Need Want

LaseMD Laser Facial Treatment

Let’s Work Together

laura@have-need-want.com
Serious inquiries only. Please note I do not accept products or services in exchange for coverage.

Where I shop

Abercrombie & Fitch

Amazon

ASOS

Bohemian Mama

Burts Bees Baby

Daily Harvest

Express

Hanna Andersson

H&M

Kohl's

Macy's

Minted

Murad

Net-A-Porter

Nordstrom

Nordstrom Rack

Revolve Clothing

Ritual

Sephora

Shopbop

SOMA

Spearmint Love

Splendid

Target

Tarte

The Container Store

The RealReal

The Styled Collection

Ulta Beauty

Walmart

Wayfair

Disclosure

Have Need Want is a part of several affiliate advertising programs. This means that if you click and/or make a purchase through certain links on this site or any related social media platforms (including twitter, facebook and pinterest), I may make a commission from that click and/or purchase. To read my full disclosure go here.

All opinions are my own and I only share brands with you that I love.

Kindergarten graduation 👨🏼‍🎓 Mason has Kindergarten graduation 👨🏼‍🎓 Mason has grown leaps and bounds this year and it wouldn’t have been possible without his incredible team of teachers!! I couldn’t be more proud of him and his accomplishments this year, from writing, spanish, music, bible study, and STEAM.
Mason’s first day of Kindergarten vs his last da Mason’s first day of Kindergarten vs his last day. Still can’t believe we’ve got an entering 1st grader and preschooler!!
New day, new mani 💅🏼 definitely giving off l New day, new mani 💅🏼 definitely giving off lover vibes and I’m here for it!! What era should I do next?

#erastour #erastourtaylorswift #eratournails
Poolside naps 😴 with my littlest one! 💕💕💕
Can I tell you a story? One thing that I was hopi Can I tell you a story?

One thing that I was hoping to get while at Disneyland was their limited edition silver drip 100 year Minnie ears. I was unaware that they were available for pre-order at the new year (otherwise I totally would have gone that route) and so when I saw they were sold out online I figured the only way I was going to be able to get a pair was during our visit to the parks. The resale market has them going for $400, $500, $600 which is absolutely insane! I knew they retailed for $175, which is already pricy for a pair of Minnie ears but I loved the look of them. 

Well, it turns out that they were completely sold out of them by mid January and they had no intention of making a second batch which made me super duper disappointed. So I’m putting it out there, in case anyone wants to hook this Disney loving mama up. If you were lucky enough to get a pair of the Disneyland, 100 year Minnie ears and are no longer wanting to have them in your collection, please reach out to me as I would love to purchase them from you!! 

#disneyland #disney100 #disney100yearsofwonder #disney100yearsofmagic #disneylandcalifornia #disneymama
Cooper’s 1st roller coaster ride + lots more fun Cooper’s 1st roller coaster ride + lots more fun on day 2 at Disneyland 

#disneylandcalifornia #disneylandpark #toddlerboystyle #hmkids #mickeymouseclubhouse #mickeymouse #disneykids #disneykidsfashion

Copyright © 2023 Have Need Want · Site design by Lennox Creative Co.

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.
You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings.

Have Need Want
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.

3rd Party Cookies

This website uses Google Analytics to collect anonymous information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages.

Keeping this cookie enabled helps us to improve our website.

Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!

Additional Cookies

This website uses the following additional cookies:

(Rewardstyle affiliate links)

Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!

Cookie Policy

More information about our Cookie Policy